Women Should Not Own Large Dogs They Cannot Physically Control
Source: Eddie Scarry. "Ladies, Don't Get A Big Dog That You Can't Control." April 17, 2026. thefederalist.com
The Gist
The author argues that women shouldn't get big dogs they can't physically handle because it's dangerous for everyone involved. He says he's seen too many small women struggling to control large dogs that lunge at other people and pets, creating safety risks.
Conclusion
Women should avoid getting large dogs if they lack the physical strength to control them in public situations
Premises
- Dog owners who cannot control their pets in public create safety risks for other people and animals
- Large dogs that lunge or act erratically can cause injury to themselves, their owners, or others
- Small-framed women often lack the physical strength needed to restrain large, energetic dogs
- Uncontrolled dogs create liability issues and potential lawsuits for their owners
- Responsible pet ownership requires the ability to maintain control of one's animal at all times
Assumptions
- Physical strength is the primary factor in controlling large dogs
- Women are generally smaller and weaker than men
- Training alone is insufficient if the owner lacks physical control capability
- Public safety should take priority over personal pet preferences
- Gender-based generalizations about physical capabilities are valid and relevant