God Answers the Prayers of Those Fighting Just Wars, Contrary to Pope Leo XIV's Claims
Source: https://www.facebook.com/americanspectator/. "When Generals Pray and Popes Object | The American Spectator | USA News and Politics." March 31, 2026. spectator.org
The Gist
The author argues that Pope Leo XIV is wrong to say God doesn't listen to prayers from those fighting wars. Using General Patton's successful prayer for good weather in WWII as proof, the author claims God does answer prayers from soldiers fighting just wars, and that the current war against Iran qualifies as such a just war.
Conclusion
God does listen to and answer the prayers of those who wage just wars, contrary to Pope Leo XIV's assertion that God rejects such prayers
Premises
- Historical evidence shows God answered General Patton's prayer for good weather during WWII, leading to military success at Bastogne
- Catholic just war theory legitimizes warfare under specific conditions including resisting aggression and protecting the innocent
- The current war against Iran meets all criteria for a just war according to Catholic doctrine
- Iran's Islamic regime is genuinely evil, oppressing its people and seeking nuclear weapons to harm infidels
- President Trump exhausted diplomatic alternatives before resorting to military action against Iran
- Military personnel have a duty to pray for protection, victory, and swift resolution of conflicts they are fighting
- Soldiers above all people understand the cost of war and therefore pray most earnestly for peace through victory
Assumptions
- Divine intervention occurs in human military conflicts
- Historical military outcomes can serve as evidence of answered prayers
- Catholic just war doctrine provides the definitive moral framework for evaluating warfare
- The Iranian regime represents absolute evil comparable to Nazi Germany
- Military victory against evil regimes advances God's justice
- Papal statements on war and peace can be factually incorrect