Cardinal McElroy wrongfully fired exorcist Rossetti for orthodox theological views on demons and UFOs
Source: https://www.facebook.com/americanspectator/. "The Exorcist and the Cardinal | The American Spectator | USA News and Politics." June 7, 2026. spectator.org
The Gist
The author argues that Cardinal McElroy unfairly fired an exorcist for suggesting UFOs might be demons in disguise. Since this idea doesn't actually contradict Catholic teaching and other respected exorcists agree, the firing seems suspicious and potentially motivated by the Cardinal's liberal agenda.
Conclusion
Cardinal McElroy's removal of Monsignor Rossetti as exorcist was unjustified and potentially suspicious given that Rossetti's views on UFOs being demonic activity align with Catholic teaching
Premises
- Rossetti's statement that UFOs may be demonic activity does not contradict Catholic Church teaching on demons
- Other respected Catholic exorcists like Fr. Chad Ripperger have made similar connections between demonic activity and UFO encounters
- Catholic doctrine teaches that demons lie, deceive, and attempt to hide their presence, making disguise as extraterrestrials plausible
- The Catholic Church has no official position on extraterrestrial life, making this a scientific rather than theological question
- Prominent Catholic thinkers like C.S. Lewis have explored similar themes without theological contradiction
- McElroy has a track record of promoting progressive positions that conflict with traditional Catholic teaching
Assumptions
- Traditional Catholic teaching on demons is correct and should be upheld
- Exorcists with extensive experience have credible insights into demonic behavior
- Cardinal McElroy's progressive positions indicate bias against orthodox Catholic views
- The removal was motivated by ideological rather than legitimate theological concerns